The future of the left since 1884

Living room

Lula's victory reflects the insecurity of Brazilians across the income spectrum, writes Andreza Aruska de Souza Santos

Share

Opinion

Around a decade ago, I stayed with a friend who worked as an assistant professor in Scotland. She shared a house with another professional. Their home was comfortable, but her bedroom was something else: beautiful bedsheets, carefully arranged pillows and decorative objects transformed that single room into a small world of its own. I remember the contrast: a highly educated professional who could afford beautiful things, but not a home of her own. Recently, I had a similar experience talking to another assistant professor in Brazil. She shares a house with three colleagues and has created a sense of homeliness through what she described as her “400-thread-count bedsheets.”

We often interpret such consumption as vanity. Why buy expensive objects when you cannot afford a house? This misunderstands the economics of aspiration. People unable to access mortgages or accumulate savings may still afford smaller pleasures, sometimes through credit. A beautiful bedroom, a designer handbag or an aesthetic treatment offers something immediate that the distant dream of homeownership cannot. Rather than being signs of prosperity, such purchases may reveal its absence: they serve as a way to participate in a society from which that same person feels increasingly excluded. This dynamic is particularly stark in Brazil.

For decades, economic progress promised a sequence of achievements: education, employment, a home, a family and retirement. Our research with young people in Brazil suggests that these aspirations remain remarkably persistent even as the possibility of achieving them has reduced significantly. Today, people study longer, enter insecure labour markets, share accommodation into adulthood and postpone having children. Military careers have become increasingly attractive, offering predictable incomes and institutional security (as well as ideas about masculinity and conservatism).

The contradiction is that, over past decades, millions in Brazil have gained access to education, consumer goods and credit, yet all the while, indebtedness, insecure employment and rising living costs have made stability elusive. This is not only about poverty; it also concerns people who work, study and consume but cannot translate their efforts into the security they expected. They are included in the economy as consumers but excluded from many of its promises.

This phenomenon is inherently political. Brazil’s recent presidential election exposed a society in which expectations have expanded faster than opportunities. Lula’s victory demonstrated the continuing strength of social inclusion, but the right’s appeal revealed the frustrations surrounding it.

A brief survey of Brazilian politics is necessary. For much of its history, Brazil cultivated a powerful narrative of national unity. We shared a language, celebrated regional diversity and rarely discussed our racial and religious divisions openly. Yet these divisions always existed, and the rise of the far right brought them into the open. Racism became more overt. Religion is another cleavage, with some on the left mocking evangelicals while parts of the evangelical movement fear the left. The north-east votes predominantly for the left, while the south leans right. Political differences increasingly shape friendships, workplaces and even where people choose to shop.

These divisions have acquired new political force in a society where aspirations have grown faster than opportunities. When people believe prosperity is expanding, sharing resources appear compatible with personal advancement. When opportunities become scarce, inclusion can come to be equated with competition.

The contemporary right has become effective at mobilising these anxieties, promising to protect opportunities for some by restricting access for others. In Brazil, affirmative action is often portrayed as a process of taking opportunities from those who worked hard but received little in return. More generally, women’s educational and professional achievements can generate resentment among men struggling to find their place.

Economic insecurity neither creates prejudice nor excuses it. But the left cannot confront these narratives through moral condemnation alone. It must address the material anxieties that make them persuasive. There is something troubling about an economy offering endless opportunities to consume but diminishing opportunities to build a life. Telling younger generations to adjust their expectations is easier when you already own your own home.

Lula’s victory shows that inclusivity can still win. But electoral victories do not resolve the frustrations that make the politics of exclusion attractive. For the left, defending rights and redistribution must go alongside creating secure employment, affordable housing and credible paths towards economic independence. The dreams of a home, a family and a secure future have not disappeared; the challenge for the left is to rebuild an economy in which they are achievable.

Image credit: Lula Oficial, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Andreza Aruska de Souza Santos

Dr Andreza Aruska de Souza Santos is the director of the Brazil Institute at King's College London

Fabian membership

Join the Fabian Society today and help shape the future of the left

You’ll receive the quarterly Fabian Review and at least four reports or pamphlets each year sent to your door

Be a part of the debate at Fabian conferences and events and join one of our network of local Fabian societies

Join the Fabian Society
Fabian Society

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close